Link to Part 1 of $70 Countertop Fix – Giani Granite Paint

 

As promised by Giani the replacement paints arrived Monday morning.

In the meantime I had figured out how to get the appearance I wanted. If you use a large section of sponge (like half of one) you get a blotchy circles look. If you use the edge of a thinner piece of sponge and use it repeatedly you get a speckled, not blotchy look. This is a case where less really is more.

After you cover the area with the big splotches using a large piece of sponge, switch to a small sliver of sponge to break it up into a finer, speckled look.

I was amazed how little it took to break up big, blotchy patches into a small speckled look. I ended up using this technique to add back some black primer, to add the brown from the new can of paint, to cut down on the Inca Gold that I felt was way too white for the appearance I wanted, and to put back the metallic copper highlights I wanted. I had purchased a Martha Stewart jar of metalic copper that I wanted in my countertops.

OCD warning: Man, where do you stop? Once I started getting the look I wanted I kept dabbing here and dabbing there with all the colors and finally had to mentally grab hold of myself and say “enough is enough!” I had a nice blend of the matte black background, a little Inca Gold, a decent amount of the Feldspar brown to lighten the overall appearance, and speckles of chocolate.

Initial process

I didn’t like the idea of trying to do all colors at one time. I did the primer, then I did 2A, the metallic copper paint, 2B, and finally 2C. I loved the appearance up until 2C — that’s when I should have started using a sliver of sponge edge. I don’t think Giani makes this painfully clear in their videos. In my opinion if you use a big section of sponge there’s no getting around a big and blotchy look.

My error

I think I made a mistake when I called Giani because the new chocolate paint was just as watery when covering the other lighter colors as the original can. No matter how much I stirred and shook the can it seemed to separate when dabbed on the lighter colors and and the edges had a watery almost like the paint was separating. I have no idea if it’s a function of the dark brown pigment — the black certainly was a solid cover — but it separated and didn’t give a solid coverage of the light colors in a lot of places.

That complaint aside, the bottom line is despite the watery brown, I was able to get exactly the look I wanted that’s all the really matters. Well, that’s not all that matters — Giani customer service was awesome. I like a company that stands behind their products.

Top coat

I watched the Giani video on how to apply the top coat and don’t think there’s much that can be added to what they said. It’s humid here so I really didn’t have any problems applying the top coat since fast drying wasn’t an issue. My big fear was dog hair — I wanted to get the top coat on and dried before hair floated in it from one of my yellow labs. They were exiled to other rooms while the paint and top coat was wet.

Due to the high humidity I kept everything off the counters for a few days and was very careful with them for the first 3 weeks. I may have gone way too far with this, but I preferred that to trashing all the work I’d put into doing the countertops.

Result

You can see more pictures of the counters on my posts for the backsplash and final kitchen update. I’m a little disappointed with the pictures since they don’t really show the shiny copper accents that area beautiful. The top coat give the counters a gorgeous depth.

I am so happy with the look of my counters that I find myself smiling every time I walk into my kitchen. Of course who wouldn’t? I’ve gone from washed out ugly to rich color and depth added by the topcoat. It’s a huge improvement.

Be sure to read my post about finding a caulk that matches.

Follow Up Notes:

Follow up note on Top Coat: I ended up with brush stokes in the top coat on the left edge of the sink. It was really bugging me so I used  600 grit sandpaper to smooth out the brush strokes and then carefully applied two coats of top coat to the sanded area. As it dried it all leveled out and there is no lap line where the new coats met the old coats. It’s nice to know you can do repairs if needed.

Also, after this touch up I set a condensating glass on it before it was completely dry and the condensation raised blisters in the top coat. Talk about panic. I thought I’d really messed up the top coat. I left it alone and came back a couple hours later to find the blisters had all settled back into the surface and you couldn’t see where the glass had been. What a relief. 

Process: if part way through the process you think your counters look awful — don’t panic! If you looked at the pictures of the watery brown paint you can see things looked pretty bad and I was scared I had made a huge mistake or would have to start all over. I’m still not happy with the watery brown paint, but I love the countertops.

Results 2 months later: The countertops still look awesome. I am careful with them — I don’t let water stand on them and don’t put things on them that I think could scratch. I suspect I’m being paranoid and will post how they are doing a few months from now.